Online Encyclopedia

Search over 40,000 articles from the original, classic Encyclopedia Britannica, 11th Edition.

SAINT BERNARD

Online Encyclopedia
Originally appearing in Volume V20, Page 704 of the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica.
Spread the word: del.icio.us del.icio.us it!

See also:

SAINT See also:BERNARD  .) At the very moment when the papacy thus attained omnipotence, symptoms of discontent and opposition arose . The Resistance bishops resisted centralization . See also:Archbishop See also:Hildebert to thePapal of See also:Tours protested to See also:Honorius IL against the exactions appeals to See also:Rome, while others complained of the and exactions of the legates, or, like See also:John of See also:Salisbury, encroach• animadverted upon the excessive See also:powers of the meets . bureaucracy at the Lateran . In the See also:councils See also:strange speeches were heard from the mouths of laymen, who were beginning to carry to extreme lengths the spirit of See also:independence with regard to Rome . When a question arose at See also:Toulouse in 116o as to the best means of settling the papal See also:schism, this audacious statement was made before the See also:kings of See also:France and See also:England: " That the best course was to See also:side with neither of the two popes; that the apostolic see had been ever a See also:burden to the princes; that See also:advantage must be taken of the schism to throw off the yoke; and that, while awaiting the See also:death of one of the competitors, the authority of the bishops was sufficient in France and England alike for the See also:government of the churches." The ecclesiastics themselves, however, were the first to denounce the abuses at Rome . The See also:treatises of Gerhoh of Reichersberg (1093–1169) abound in trenchant attacks upon the greed and venality of the See also:Curia, the arrogance and See also:extortion of the legates, the abuse of exemptions and appeals, and the See also:German policy of See also:Adrian IV. and See also:Alexander III . In his efforts to make the papal institution entirely worthy of its See also:mission St See also:Bernard himself did not shrink from presenting to the papacy " the See also:mirror in which it could recognize its deformities." In See also:common with all enlightened See also:opinion, he complained bitterly of the excessive multiplication of exemptions, of the exaggerated See also:extension of appeals to Rome, of the luxury of the See also:Roman See also:court, of the venality of the cardinals, and of the injury done to the traditional See also:hierarchy by the very extent of the papal See also:power, which was calculated to turn the strongest See also:head . In St Bernard's See also:treatise De See also:consideration, addressed to See also:Pope See also:Eugenius III., the papacy receives as many reprimands and attacks as it does marks of See also:affection and friendly counsel . To warn Eugenius against See also:pride, Bernard reminds him in biblical terms that an insensate See also:sovereign on a See also:throne resembles " an See also:ape upon a housetop," and that the dignity with which he is invested does not prevent him from being a See also:man, that is, " a being, naked, poor, miserable, made for toil and not for honours." To his thinking, See also:poison and the See also:dagger were less to be feared by the pope than the lust of power . Ambition and cupidity were the source of the most deplorable abuses in the Roman See also:Church . The cardinals, said Bernard, were satraps who put pomp before the truth .

He was at a loss to justify the unheard-of luxury of the Roman court . " I do not find," he said, " that St See also:

Peter ever appeared in public loaded with See also:gold and jewels, clad in See also:silk, mounted on a See also:white See also:mule, surrounded by soldiers and followed by a brilliant See also:retinue . In the glitter that environs thee, rather wouldst See also:thou be taken for the successor of See also:Constantine than for the successor of Peter." Rome, however, had greater dangers to See also:cope with than the indignant reproofs of her See also:friends the monks, and the opposition Growth of of the bishops, who were displeased at the spectacle Heretical of their authority waning See also:day by day . It was at sects. this See also:period that the See also:Catholic edifice of the See also:middle ages began to be shaken by the boldness of philosophical See also:speculation as applied to theological studies and also by the growth of See also:heresy . Hitherto more tolerant of heresy than the See also:local authorities, the papacy now See also:felt compelled to take defensive See also:measures against it, and especially against Albigensianism, which had made See also:great strides in the See also:south of France since the middle of the 12th See also:century . See also:Innocent II., Eugenius III. and Alexander III. excommunicated the sectaries of See also:Languedoc and their abettors, Alexander even sending armed See also:missions tohunt them down and punish them . But the See also:preaching of the papal legates, even when supported by military demonstrations, had no effect; and the Albigensian question, together with other questions vital for the future of the papacy, remained unsettled and more formidable than ever when Innocent III. was elected . 3 . Period from Innocent III. to Alexander ,I V . (1198-1261).—Under the pontificates of Innocent III. and his five immediate successors the Roman See also:monarchy seemed to have Innocent reached the See also:pinnacle of its moral See also:prestige, religious III•, II98• authority and temporal power, and this development 1216• was due in great measure to Innocent III. himself . Between the perhaps excessive admiration of Innocent's biographer, See also:Friedrich von Hurter, and the cooler estimate of a later historian, See also:Felix Rocquain, who, after taking into consideration Innocent's See also:political mistakes, lack of foresight and numerous disappointments and failures, concludes that his reputation has been much exaggerated, it is possible to See also:steer a middle course and See also:form a See also:judgment that is at once impartial and conformable to the See also:historical facts . Innocent was an eminent jurist and canoeist, and never ceased to use his immense power in the service of the See also:law .

Indeed, a great See also:

part of his See also:life was passed in See also:hearing pleadings and pronouncing judgments, and few sovereigns have ever worked so industriously or shown such solicitude for the impartial exercise of their judicial functions . It is difficult to comprehend Innocent's extraordinary activity . Over and above the See also:weight of political affairs, he See also:bore resolutely for eighteen years the overwhelming burden of the See also:presidency of a tribunal before which the whole of See also:Europe came to plead . To him, also, in his capacity of theologian, the whole of Europe submitted every obscure, delicate or controverted question, whether legal problem or See also:case of See also:conscience . This, undoubtedly, was the part of his task that Innocent preferred, and it was to this, as well as to his much overrated moral and theological treatises, that he owed his enormous contemporary prestige . As a statesman, he certainly committed See also:grave faults—through excess of See also:diplomatic subtlety, lack of forethought, and sometimes even through ingenuousness; but it must with See also:justice be admitted that, in spite of his reputation for pugnacity and obstinacy, he never failed, either by temperament or on principle, to exhaust every peaceful expedient in settling questions . He was averse from violence, and never resorted to bellicose acts or to the employment of force See also:save in the last extremity . If his policy miscarried in several quarters it was eminently successful in others; and if we consider the sum of his efforts to achieve the See also:programme of the See also:medieval papacy, it cannot be denied that the extent of his See also:rule and the profound See also:influence he exerted on his times entitle him to be regarded as the most perfect type of medieval pope and one of the most powerful figures in See also:history . A superficial glance at Innocent's See also:correspondence is sufficient to convince us that he was pre-eminently concerned for the See also:reformation and moral welfare of the Church, and The See also:Fourth was animated by the best intentions for the re-estab- Lateran lishment in the ecclesiastical See also:body of See also:order, See also:peace and See also:council, respect for the hierarchy . This was one of the prin-1215 . cipal See also:objects of his activity, and this important side of his See also:work received decisive See also:sanction by the promulgation of the decrees of the fourth Lateran Council (1215) . At this council almost all the questions at issue related to reform, and many give See also:evidence of great breadth of mind, as well as of a very acute sense of contemporary necessities .

Innocent's letters, however, not only reveal that See also:

superior See also:wisdom which can take into See also:account See also:practical needs and relax severity of principle at the right moment, as well as that spirit of tolerance and See also:equity which is opposed to the excess of zeal and intellectual narrowness of subordinates, but they also prove that, in the See also:internal government of the Church, he was See also:bent on gathering into his hands all the See also:motive threads, and that he stretched the absolutist tradition to its furthest limits, intervening in the most trifling acts in the lives of the See also:clergy, and regarding it as an See also:obligation of his See also:office to See also:act and think for all . The heretic peril, which increased during his pontificate, forced him to take decisive measures against the Albigenses in the south of France, but before proscribing them he spent ten years (1198–1208) in endeavouring to convert the misbelievers, and history should not The forget the pacific See also:character of these See also:early efforts . It Albigensian was because they did not succeed that See also:necessity and See also:crusades the violence of human passions subsequently forced him into a course of See also:action which he had not chosen and which led him further than he wished to go . When he was compelled to See also:decree the Albigensian crusade he endeavoured more than once to discontinue the work, which had become perverted, and to curb the crusading ardour of See also:Simon de See also:Montfort . Failing in his See also:attempt to maintain the religious character of the crusade, he wished to prevent it from ending secularly in its extreme consequence and logical outcome . On several occasions he defended the cause of moderation and justice against the fanatical crusaders, but he never had the See also:energy to make it prevail . It is very doubtful whether this was possible, and an impartial historian must take into account the insuperable difficulties encountered by the medieval popes in their efforts to See also:stem the See also:flood of fanaticism . It was more particularly in the definitive constitution of the temporal and political power of the papacy, in the extension of Papal what may be called Roman imperialism, that See also:chance Imperialism favoured his efforts and enabled him to pursue his under conquests farthest . This imperialism was undoubt-Innecentlll. edly of a See also:special nature; it rested on moral authority and political and See also:financial power rather than on material and military strength . But it is no less certain that Innocent attempted to subject the kings of Europe by making them his tributaries and vassals . He wished to acquire the mastery of souls by unifying the faith and centralizing the priesthood, but he also aspired to possess temporal supremacy, if not as See also:direct owner, at least as suzerain, over all the See also:national crowns, and thus to realize the See also:idea with which he was penetrated and which he himself expressed clearly . He wished to be at once pope and See also:emperor, See also:leader of See also:religion and universal sovereign .

And, in fact, he exercised or claimed suzerain rights, together with the political and pecuniary advantages accruing, over the greater number of the See also:

lay sovereigns of his See also:time . He was more or less effectively the supreme temporal See also:chief of the See also:kingdom of See also:Sicily and See also:Naples, See also:Sardinia, the states of the Iberian See also:peninsula (See also:Castile, See also:Leon, See also:Navarre and See also:Portugal), See also:Aragon (which, under Peter II., was the type of See also:vassal and tributary kingdom of the Roman power), the Scandinavian states, the kingdom of See also:Hungary, the Slav states of Bohemia, See also:Poland, See also:Servia, Bosnia and See also:Bulgaria, and the See also:Christian states founded in See also:Syria by the crusaders of the 12th century . The success of Roman imperialism was particularly remarkable in England, where Innocent was confronted by one of the See also:principal potentates of the See also:West, by the See also:heir of the power that had been founded by two statesmen of the first See also:rank, See also:William the Conqueror and See also:Henry II . In See also:Richard I. and John he had exceptionally authoritative adversaries; but after one of the fiercest See also:wars ever waged by the See also:civil power against the Church, Innocent at length gained over John the most See also:complete victory that has ever been won by a religious potentate over a temporal sovereign, and constrained him to Innocentm. make complete submission . In 1213 the pope and John of became not only the nominal suzerain but, de facto England. and de :lure, the veritable sovereign of England, and during the last years of John and the first years of Henry III. he governed England effectively by his legates . This was the most striking success of Innocent's See also:diplomacy and the culminating point of his See also:secular work . The papacy, however, encountered serious obstacles, at first at the very centre of the papal See also:empire, at Rome, where the pope had to contend with the party of communal See also:autonomy for ten years before being able to secure the mastery at Rome . His Innocent///., immense authority narrowly escaped destruction Rome and but a See also:stone's-throw from the Lateran See also:palace; but See also:Italy the victory finally rested with him, since the Roman See also:people could not dispense with the Roman Church, to which it owed its existence . Reared in the nurture of the pope, the populace of the See also:Tiber renounced its stormy See also:liberty in 1209,and accepted the peace and order that a beneficent See also:master gave; but when Innocent attempted to extend to the whole of Italy the regime of paternal subjection that had been so successful at Rome, the difficulties of the enterprise surpassed the powers even of a leader of religion . He succeeded in imposing his will on the nobles and communes in the patrimony of St Peter, and, as See also:guardian of Henry VI.'s son See also:Frederick, was for some time able to conduct the government of the kingdom of the Two Sicilies, but in his claims on the See also:rest of Italy the failure of the temporal power was See also:manifest . He was unable, either by diplomacy or force of arms, to make See also:Italian unity redound to the exclusive benefit of the See also:Holy See . Nor was his failure due to lack of activity or energy, but rather to the insuperable obstacles in his path—the See also:physical configuration of Italy, and, above all, the invincible repugnance of the Italian municipalities to submit to the mastery of a religious power .

As far as the Empire was concerned, chance at first favoured Innocent . For ten years a See also:

Germany weakened and divided by the rivalry of See also:Philip of See also:Swabia and See also:Otto of See also:Brunswick Innocent III. See also:left his hands See also:free to act in Italy, and his pontificate and the marks a period of See also:comparative quiet in the ardent Empire. conflict between pope and emperor which continued throughout the middle ages . Not until 1210, when Otto of Brunswick turned against the pope to whom he owed his See also:crown, was Innocent compelled to open hostilities; and the struggle ended in a victory for the Curia . Frederick II., the new emperor created by Innocent, began by handing over his See also:country to Rome and sacrificing the rights of the Empire to the See also:union of the two great authorities of the' Christian See also:world . In his dealings with Frederick, Innocent experienced grievous vicissitudes and disappointments, but finally became master of the situation . One nation only—the France of Philip See also:Augustus—was able to remain outside the Roman vassalage . There is not a word, in the documents concerning the relations of Philip Augustus with Rome, from which we may conclude that the Capetian crown submitted, or that the papacy wished to impose upon it the effective See also:suzerainty of the Holy See . Innocent III. had been able to encroach on France at one point only, when the Albigensian crusade had enabled him to exercise over the See also:southern fiefs conquered by Simon de Montfort a political and secular supremacy in the form of collections of moneys . Finally, Innocent III. was more fortunate than his predecessors, and, if he did not succeed in carrying out his projected crusade and recovering the Holy Places, he at least benefited by the Franco-Venetian expedition of 1202 . Europe refused to take any direct action against the Mussulman, but Latin See also:feudalism, Latin See also:con. assembled at See also:Venice, diverted the crusade by an act quest actin-of formal disobedience, marched on See also:Constantinople, stantinopte. seized thg See also:Greek Empire and founded a Latin Empire in its See also:place; and Innocent had to accept the fait accompli . Though condemning it on principle, he turned it to the interests of the Roman Church as well as of the universal Church . With joy and pride he welcomed the See also:Byzantine See also:East into the circle of vassal peoples and kingdoms of Rome See also:bound politically to the see of St Peter, and with the same emotions beheld the patriarchate of Constantinople at last recognize Roman supremacy .

But from this enormous increase of territory and influence arose a whole See also:

series of new and difficult problems . The court of Rome had to substitute for the old Greek hierarchy a hierarchy of Latin bishops; to force the remaining Greek clergy to practise the beliefs and See also:rites of the Roman religion and See also:bow to the supremacy of the pope; to maintain in the See also:Greco-Latin Eastern Church the necessary order, morality and subordination; to defend it against the greed and violence of the nobles and barons who had founded the Latin Empire; and to compel the leaders of the new empire to submit to the apostolic power and execute its commands . In his endeavours to carry out the whole of this programme, Innocent III. met with insuperable obstacles and many disappointments . On the one See also:hand, the Greeks were unwilling to abandon their religion and national cult, and scarcely recognized the ecclesiastical supremacy of the papacy . On the other hand, the upstart Latin emperors, far from proving 698 submissive and humble tools, assumed with the See also:purple the habits and pretensions of the sovereigns they had dispossessed . Nevertheless, Innocent left his successors a much Vaster and more See also:stable political dominion than that which he had received from his predecessors, since it comprised both East and West; and his five immediate successors were able to preserve this ascendancy . They even extended the limits of Roman impetial-1sm by converting the pagans of the Baltic to See also:Christianity, and further reinforced the work of ecclesiastical centralization by enlisting in their service a force which had recently come into existence and was rapidly becoming popular—the mendicant orders, and notably the See also:Dominicans and See also:Franciscans . The The Friars Roman power was also increased by the formation and the of the See also:universities—privileged corporations of Universities, masters and students, which escaped the local power of the See also:bishop and his See also:chancellor only to place themselves under the direction and supervision of the Holy See . See also:Mistress of the entire Christian organism, Rome thus gained See also:control of inter-national See also:education, and the mendicant monks who formed her devoted See also:militia lost no time in monopolizing the professorial chairs . Although the ecclesiastical monarchy continued to gain strength, the successors of Innocent III. made less use than he of their immense power . Under See also:Gregory IX . (1227—1241) and Innocent IV .

(1243–1254) the conflict between the priesthood and the Empire was revived by the enigmatic Frederick II., the polyglot and lettered emperor, the friend of See also:

Saracens, the See also:despot who, in youth styled "See also:king of priests," in later years personified ideas that were directly opposed to the medieval See also:theocracy; and the struggle lasted nearly See also:thirty years . The See also:Hohenstaufen succumbed to it, and the papacy itself received a terrible See also:shock, which shook its vast empire to the See also:foundations . Nevertheless, the first See also:half of the 13th century may be regarded as the See also:grand See also:epoch of medieval papal history . Supreme in See also:culmination Europe, the papacy gathered into a body of See also:doctrine of the Papal the decisions given in virtue of its enormous de facto Power. power, and promulgated its collected decrees and maxilla to form the immutable law of the Christian world . Innocent III., Honorius III. and Gregory IX. employed their jurists to collect the most important of their rulings, and Gregory's decrees became the definitive repository of the See also:canon law . Besides making See also:laws for the Christendom of the See also:present and the future, these popes employed themselves in giving a more See also:regular form to their principal administrative See also:organ, the offices of the Curia . The development of the Roman See also:chancery is also a characteristic sign of the See also:evolution that was taking place . From the time of Innocent III. the usages of the apostolic See also:scribes become transformed into precise rules, which for the most part remained in force until the 15th century . 4 . Period. from See also:Urban IV. to See also:Benedict XI . (1261–1305).—This period comprises 13 pontificates, all of See also:short duration (three or four years at the most, and some only a few months)., with the exception of that of See also:Boniface VIII., who was pope for nine years . This accidental fact constitutes a See also:prime difference in favour of the preceding period, in which there were only five pontiffs during the first sixty years of the 13th century .

Towards the end of the 13th century the See also:

directors of the Christian world occupied the throne of St Peter for too short a time to be able to make their See also:personal views prevail or to execute their political projects at leisure after ripe meditation . Whatever the merit of a Gregory X. or a See also:Nicholas III., the brevity of their pontificates prevented any one of these ephemeral sovereigns from being a great pope . But other and far more important See also:differences characterize this period . Although there was no theoretical restriction to Influence of the temporal supremacy and religious power of the the Power papacy, certain historical facts of great importance of France. contributed to the fatal diminution of their extent . The first of these was the preponderance of the See also:French monarchy and nation in Europe . Founded by the conquests of Philip Augustus and See also:Louis VIII. and legitimated and extended by the policy and moral influence of the crowned See also:saint, Louis IX., [1087-1305 the French monarchy enjoyed undisputed supremacy at the end of the 13th century and the beginning of the 14th; and this See also:hegemony of France was manifested, not only by the extension of the direct power exercised .by the French kings over all the neighbouring nationalities, but also by the See also:establishment of Capetian dynasties in the kingdom of the Two Sicilies and in Hungary . From this time the sovereign of Rome, like other sovereigns, had to submit to French influence . But, whereas the pope was sometimes compelled to become the See also:instrument of the policy of the kings of France or the adventurers of their See also:race, he was often able to utilize this new and pervading force for the realization of his own designs, although he endeavoured from time to time, but without enduring success, to shake off the overwhelming yoke of the French . In short, it was in the See also:sphere of French interests much more than in that of the See also:general interests of Latin Christendom that the activities of these popes were exerted . The fact of many of the popes being of French See also:birth and France the See also:field of their diplomacy shows that the supreme pontificate was already becoming French in character . This See also:change was a prelude to the more or less complete subjection of the papacy to French influence which took place in the following century at the period of the " Babylonish Captivity," the violent reaction personified by Boniface VIII. affording but a brief See also:respite in this irresistible evolution . It was the French-man Urban IV .

(1261–1264) who called See also:

Charles of See also:Anjou into Italy to combat the last heirs of Frederick II. and thus paved the way for the establishment of the Angevin See also:dynasty on the throne of Naples . Under See also:Clement IV . (1265–1268) an agreement was concluded by which Sicily was handed over to the See also:brother of St Louis, and the victories of See also:Benevento (1266) and Taglia-COZZO (1267) assured the See also:triumph of the See also:Guelph party and enabled the Angevins to plant themselves definitely on Neapolitan See also:soil . See also:Conradin's tragic and inevitable end closed the last act of the secular struggle between the Holy See and the Empire . Haunted by the recollection of that formidable conflict and lulled in the See also:security of the Great See also:Interregnum, which was to render Germany See also:long powerless, the papacy thought merely of the support that France could give, and paid no heed to the dangers threatened by the extension of Charles of Anjou's monarchy in central and See also:northern Italy . The See also:Visconti Gregory X . (1271–1276) made an attempt to bring about a reaction against the tendency which had influenced his two