Search over 40,000 articles from the original, classic Encyclopedia Britannica, 11th Edition.
|
See also:ESCHATOLOGY (Gr. &rXaros, last, and A6yos, See also:science; the " See also:doctrine of last things ")
, a theological See also:term derived from the New Testament phrases " the last See also:day " (iv rp EkXhrp ipi See also: It may also be thought of as retributive, as a reversal of present conditions so that the miserable are comforted, and the prosperous laid See also:low, or as a See also:reward or See also:punishment for See also:good or evil See also:desert here . See also:Personal identity may be absorbed, as in the transmigration of souls, or it may even be denied, while the good or See also:bad result of one life is held to determine the weal or woe of another . The See also:scene of the future life may be thought of on See also:earth, in some distant See also:part of it, or above the earth, in the See also:sky, See also:sun, See also:moon or stars, or beneath the earth . The abodes of See also:bliss and the places of torment may be distinguished, or one last dwelling-See also:place may be affirmed for all the dead . Sometimes the good find their abiding See also:home with the gods; sometimes a number of heavens of varying degrees of blessedness is recognized (see F . B . See also:Jevons, An Introduction to the History of See also:Religion, chs. xxi. and xxii., 1902; and J . A . See also:MacCulloch's See also:Comparative See also:Theology, xiv., 1902) . (i) See also:Confucius, though unwilling to discuss any questions concerning the dead, by approving ancestor-See also:worship recognized a future life . (2) See also:Taoism promises immortality as the reward of merit . (3) The See also:Book of the Dead—a See also:guide-book for the departed on his See also:long See also:journey in the unseen world to the See also:abode of the blessed—shows the See also:attention the See also:Egyptian religion Bastes Religions. gave to the state of the dead . Although the Baby- lonian (4) religion presents a very gloomy view of the world of 't he dead, it is not without a few faint glimpses of a See also:hope that a few mortals at least may gain deliverance from the dread See also:doom . (5) A characteristic feature of See also:Indian thought is the transmigration of the soul from one mode of life to another, the See also:physical See also:condition of each being determined by the moral and religious See also:character of the preceding . But deliverance from this See also:cycle of existences, which is conceived as misery, is promised by means of See also:speculation and See also:asceticism . Denying the continuance of the soul, See also:Buddhism affirmed a continuity of moral consequences (See also:Karma), each successive life being determined by the See also:total moral result of the preceding life . Its See also:doctrine of salvation was a guide to, if not See also:absolute non-existence, yet cessation of all consciousness of existence (See also:Nirvana) . Later Buddhism has, however, a doctrine of many heavens and hells . (6) In Zoroastrianism not only was continuance of life recognized, but a strict retribution was taught . See also:Heaven and See also:hell were very clearly distinguished, and each soul according to its See also:works passed to the one or to the other . But this faith did not concern itself only with the future See also:lot of the individual soul . It was also interested in the See also:close of the world's history, and taught a decisive, final victory of Ormuzd over See also:Ahriman, of the forces of good over the forces of evil . It is not at all improbable that Jewish See also:eschatology in its later developments was powerfully influenced by the See also:Persian faith . (7) Mahommedanism reproduces and exaggerates the See also:lower features of popular Jewish and Christian eschatology (see the See also:separate articles on these religions) . In the Old Testament we can trace the See also:gradual development of an ever more definite doctrine of " the final condition of See also:man and the world." This is regarded as the last See also:stage in old Testa- a moral See also:process, a redemptive purpose of See also:God . The merle eschatology of the Old Testament is thus closely connected with, but not limited by, Messianic hope, as there are eschatological teachings that are not Messianic . As the Old Testament See also:revelation is concerned primarily with the elect nation, and only secondarily (in the later writings) with the individual persons composing it, we follow the See also:order of importance as well as of See also:time in dealing first with the See also:people . The universalism which marks the promise to the See also:seed of the woman (Gen. iii . 15) appears also in the blessing of See also:Noah (ix . 25) . In the promise to See also:Abraham (xii . 3) this universal good is directly related to God's particular purpose for His chosen people; so also in the blessing of See also:Jacob (xlix.) and of See also:Moses (Deut. xxxiii.) . See also:David's last words (2 Sam. See also:xxiii.) blend together his See also:desire that his See also:family should retain the kingship, and his aspiration for a See also:kingdom of righteousness on earth . The conception of the " Day of the See also:Lord " is frequent and prominent in the prophets, and the sense given to the phrase by the people and by the prophets throws into bold See also:relief the contrast between popular beliefs and the prophetic faith . The people simply expected deliverance from their miseries and burdens by the intervention of Yahweh, because He had chosen See also:Israel for His people . The prophets had an ethical conception of Yahweh; the See also:sin of His own people and of other nations called for His intervention in See also:judgment as the moral ruler of the world . But judgment they conceived as preparing for redemption . The day of the Lord is always an eschatological conception, as the term is applied to the final and universal judgment, and not to any less decisive intervention of God in the course of human history . In the pre-exilic prophets the judgment of God is " primarily on Israel, although it also embraces the nations "; during the See also:Exile and at the Restoration the judgment is represented as falling on the nations while redemption is being wrought for God's people; after the Restoration the people of God is again threatened, but still the warning of judgment is mainly directed towards the nations and deliverance is promised to Israel . As the manifestation of God in See also:grace as well as judgment, the day of the Lord will bring joy to Israel and even to the world . See also:Asa day of judgment it is accompanied by terrible See also:convulsions of nature (not to be taken figuratively, but probably intended literally by the prophets in accordance with their view of the absolute subordination of nature to the divine purpose for man) . It ushers in the Messianic age . While the moral issues are finally determined by this day, yet the world of the Messianic age is painted with the See also:colours of the See also:prophet's own surroundings . Israel is restored to its own See also:land, and to it the other nations are brought into subjugation, by force or persuasion . The contributions of the Old Testament to Christian eschatology embrace these features: " (i) The manifestation or advent of God; (2) the universal judgment; (3) behind the judgment the coming of the perfect kingdom of the Lord, when all Israel shall be saved and when the nations shall be partakers of their salvation; and (4) the finality and eternity of this condition, that which constitutes the blessedness of the saved people being the Presence of God in the midst of them—this last point corresponding to. the Christian See also:idea of heaven " (A . B . See also:Davidson, in See also:Hastings's See also:Bible See also:Dictionary, i. p . 738) . This hope is for the people on this earth though transfigured . To the individual it would seem at first only old age is promised (Is. lxv . 2o; Zech. viii . 4), but the abolition of death itself is also declared (Is. See also:xxv . 8) . The resurrection, which appears at first as a revival of the dead nation (Hos. vi . 2; Ez. See also:xxxvii . 12-14), is afterwards promised for the pious individuals (Is. See also:xxvi . 19), so that they too may See also:share in the See also:national restoration .. Only in See also:Daniel xii . 2 is taught a resurrection of the wicked " to shame and See also:everlasting contempt " as well as of the righteous to " everlasting life." It was only at the Exile, when the nation ceased to be, that the See also:worth of the individual came to be recognized, and the hopes given to the nation were claimed for the individual . In dealing with the individual eschatology we must carefully distinguish the popular ideas regarding death and the hereafter which Israel shared with the other Semitic peoples, from the intuitions, inferences, aspirations evoked in the pious by the divine revelation itself . The former have not the moral significance or the religious value of the latter . The starting-point of the development was the common belief that the dead continued to exist in an unsubstantial mode of life, but cut off from fellowship with God and man; but faith See also:left this far behind . Sheol is the common abode of the righteous and the ungodly: life there is shadowy and feeble, but seems to continue in a wavering and dim reflection features of this life . As the present life is, however, determined by moral issues, and as death does not See also:change man's relation to God, moral considerations could not be absolutely excluded from the future life . A forward step had to be taken . Pious men, in fellowship with God, when they faced the fact of death, were led either to See also:challenge its right, or to give a new meaning to it . Either there was a protest against death itself, and a demand for immortality (Ps. xvi . 9-11), or death was conceived as something different for the See also:saint and for the sinner; fellowship with God would not and could not be interrupted (Ps. xlix . 14, 15, lxxiii . 17-28) . The See also:vision of God is anticipated after death's, See also:sleep (Ps. xvii . 15; See also:Job xix . 25-27) . This belief in individual immortality is expressed poetically and obscurely: it is later than the eschatology of the people . It assumes the moral distinction of the righteous and the ungodly, and seeks a See also:solution for the problem of the lack of See also:harmony of present character and condition . Its deepest See also:motive, however, is religious . The soul once in fellowship with God cannot even by death be separated from God . The individual hoped that he would live to share. the nation's good, and thus the two streams of Old Testament eschatology at last flow together . It is in the apocryphal and apocalyptic literature of Judaism that the fullest development of eschatology can be traced . Four words may serve to See also:express the difference of the Apocydoctrine of these writings and the teaching of the Old pha/and Testament . Eschatology was universalized (God was Apocaiyprecognized as the creator and moral See also:governor of all See also:tic books. the world), individualized (God's judgment was directed, not to nations in a future age, but to individuals in a future life), transcendentalized (the future age was more and more contrasted with the present, and the transition from the one to the other was not expected as the result of See also:historical movements, but of miraculous divine acts), and dogmatized (the See also:attempt was made to systematize in some measure the vague and varied prophetic anticipations) . Only a very brief See also:summary of the conceptions current in these writings can be given . The coming of the See also:Messiah will be preceded by the Last Woes . The Messiah is very variously conceived: (r) " a passive, though supreme member of the Messianic Kingdom "; (2) " an active See also:warrior who slays his enemies with his own See also:hand "; (3) " one who slays his enemies by the word of his mouth, and rules by virtue of his. See also:justice, faith and holiness "; (4) a supernatural See also:person, " eternal Ruler and See also:Judge of Mankind " (R .
H
.
See also: 24) . Here See also:corporal as well as spiritual punishment was endured; it was inflicted on apostate See also:Jews or the wicked generally; the righteous witnessed its initial stages but not its final See also:form . In later Judaism it was the See also:purgatory of faithless Jews, who at last reached See also:Paradise, but it remained the place of eternal torment for the Gentiles . Paradise was sometimes regarded as the See also:division of Sheol to which the righteous passed after death, but at others it was conceived as the heavenly abode of Moses, Enoch and See also:Elijah, to which other saints would pass after the last judgment . The eschatology of the New Testament attaches itself not only to that of the Old Testament but also to that of contemporary Judaism, but it avoids the extravagances of the latter . New See also:Tea- Not at all systematic, it is occasional, See also:practical, torment . poetical and dominantly evangelical, laying stress on the hope of the righteous rather than the doom of the wicked . The teaching of Jesus centres, according to the Synoptists, in the See also:great idea of the " Kingdom of God," which is already present in the teacher Himself, but also future as regards its completion . In some parables a gradual realization of the kingdom is indicated (Matt. xiii.); in other utterances its consummation is connected with Christ's own return, His Parousia (Matt. See also:xxiv . 3, 37, 39), the time of which, however, is unknown even to Himself (See also:Mark xiii . 32) . In this eschatological discourse (Matt. xxiv., xxv.) He speaks of the destruction of See also:Jerusalem and of the end of the world as near, and seemingly as one . This is in accordance with the characteristic of prophecy, which See also:sees in " timeless sequence " events which are historically separated from one another . While the Return is represented in the Synoptists as an See also:external event, it is conceived in the See also:fourth See also:gospel as an See also:internal experience in the operation of the Spirit on the believer (John xiv . 16-2r); nevertheless here also the Parousia in the synoptic sense is looked for (John xxi . 22; cf. z John ii . 28) . ' The See also:object of the Second Coming is the See also:execution of judgment by Christ (Matt. xxv . 31), both individual (xxii . 1-14) and universal (xiii . 36-42) . The present subjective judgment, in which men determine their destiny by their attitude to Christ,on which the fourth gospel See also:lays stress (John iii . 17-21, ix . 30), is not inconsistent with the anticipation of a final judgment (John xii . 48, v . 27) . This judgment presupposes the resurrection, belief in which was rejected by the See also:Sadducees, but accepted by the See also:Pharisees and the See also:majority of the Phartsees Jewish PeoPleS and confirmed by Christ, not only as an ducandees . . individual spiritual renovation (John v . 25, 26), but as a universal physical resuscitation (28 and 29; Matt. xxii . 30) . This resurrection is of the unjust as well as the just (Matt. v . 29, 30, X . 28; See also:Luke xiv . 14) . On the Intermediate State Jesus does not speak clearly . He uses the term Hades twice metaphorically (Matt. xi . 23, xvi. i8), and once in a See also:parable, the " See also:Rich Man and See also:Lazarus " (Luke xvi . 23), in which he employs the current phrases such as " Abraham's bosom " (See also:verse 22), without any definite doctrinal intention, to unveil the secrets of the hereafter by confirming with His authority the common beliefs of His time . The term Paradise (Luke xxiii . 43) seems to be used " in a large and See also:general sense as a word of hope and comfort," and we need not attach to it any of the more definite associations which it had in Jewish eschatology . When he speaks of death as " sleep " (Luke viii . 52; John xi . II) it is to give men gentler and sweeter thoughts of it, not to inculcate the doctrine of an intermediate state as an unconscious condition . There are words which suggest rather the hope of an immediate entrance of the just into the See also:Father's See also:house and See also:glory (John xiv . 2, 3, xvii . 24) . He spoke frequently and distinctly both of final reward for the righteous and final See also:penalty for the wicked . " The recompense of the righteous is described as an See also:inheritance, entrance into the kingdom, treasure in heaven, an existence like the angelic, a place prepared, the Father's house, the joy of the Lord, life, eternal life and the like; and there is no intimation that the reward is capable of change, that the condition is a terminable one . The retribution of the wicked is described as death, See also:outer darkness, weeping and wailing and gnashing of See also:teeth, the undying See also:worm, the quenchless See also:fire, exclusion from the kingdom, eternal punishment and the like " (S . D . J . Salmond in Hastings's Bible Dictionary, p . 752) . Degrees of See also:award are recognized (Luke xii . 47, 48) . Gehenna is applied to the condition of the lost (Matt. xviii . 9) . Two sayings are held to point to a terminable penalty (Matt. v . 25, 26, xii . 31, 32), but the one is so figurative and the other so obscure, that we are not warranted in See also:drawing any such definite conclusion from either of them . The finality of destiny seems to be unmistakably expressed (Matt. vii . 23, X . 33, xiii . 30, xxv . 46, XXVi . 24; Mark ix . 43-48, viii . 36; Luke ix . 26; John iii . 16, viii . 21, 24) . No second opportunity for deciding the issue of life or death is recognized by Jesus . The apostolic eschatology presents resemblance amid difference . See also:Jude (v . 6), as well as 2 Peter (ii . 4), refers to the judgment of the fallen angels . 2 Peter describes the place of their detention as See also:Tartarus, and teaches that Christ's Parousia is to bring the whole present See also:system of things to its conclusion, and the world itself to an end (iii. ro, 13) . After the destruction of the existing order by fire, " a new heaven and a new earth " will appear as the abode of righteousness . The question of greatest See also:interest in r Peter is the relation of two passages in it, the See also:preaching to the See also:spirits in See also:prison (iii . 18-22) and the preaching of the Gospel to the dead (iv . 6) to the " larger hope." Peter's discourse also contains a phrase which suggests the belief of a descent of Christ into Hades in the See also:interval between His death and His resurrection (Acts ii . 31) . No certainty has been reached in the See also:interpretation of these passages, but they may suggest to the Christian mind the expectation that the final destiny of no soul can be fixed until in some way or other, in this life or the next, the opportunity of decision for or against Christ has been given . The phrase " the times of restoration of all things " (iii . 21) is too vague in itself, and is too isolated in its context to See also:warrant the dogmatic teaching of universalism, although there are other passages which seem to point towards the same See also:goal . While John's See also:Apocalypse is distinctly eschatological, the Epistles and the Gospels often give these conceptions an ethical and spiritual import, without, however, excluding the eschatological . Life is present while eternal (1 John v . 12, 13), but it is also future (ii . 25) . There is expected a future manifestation of Christ as He is, and what the believer himself will be does not yet appear (iii . 2) . The writer speaks of the last See also:hour (ii . 18), the See also:Antichrist-that cometh (ii . 22, iv . 3), and the Christian's full reward (2 John v . 8) as well as the Parousia (r John ii . 28) . The Apocalypse reproduces much of the current Jewish eschatology . A millennial reign of Christ on earth is interposed between the first resurrection, confined to the saints and especially the martyrs, and the second resurrection for the See also:rest of the dead . A final outburst of Satan's See also:power is followed by his overthrow and the Last Judgment . Although See also:Paul sometimes describes the Kingdom of God as present (Rom. xiv . 17; 1 See also:Cor. iv . 2o; See also:Col. i . 13), it is usually represented as future . The Parousia fills a large place in his thought, and, if more prominent in his earlier writings, is not altogether absent from his later, although the expectation of personal survival does seem to grow less confident (cf. r Cor. xv . 51 and Phil. i . 20-24) . The doctrines of the Resurrection, the Last Judgment, the Reward of the Righteous and the Punishment of the Wicked are not less distinctly expressed than in the other apostolic writings . See also:Peculiar elements in Paul's eschatology are the doctrines of the Rapture of the Saints (1 Thess. iv . 17) and the Man of Sin (2 Thess. ii . 3-6), but these have See also:affinities elsewhere . A reference to the millennial reign of Christ in the See also:period between the two resurrections is sometimes sought in 1 Cor. xv . 22-24; but it is not a See also:chronology of the last things Paul is here giving . So also a See also:justification for the doctrine of purgatory is sought in iii . 12-15 ; but the day and the fire are of the last judgment . A descent of Christ into Hades, implying an See also:extension of the opportunity of grace such as is supposed to be taught in r Peter, is also discovered in the obscure statements in Rom. x . 7 (where Paul is freely quoting Dent. See also:xxx . 11-14), and Eph. iv. ro (where he is commenting on Ps. lxviii . 18) . Universal restoration is inferred from 1 Cor. xv . 24-28, " God all in all," Phil. ii . 10-r 1, every See also:knee bowing to, and every See also:tongue confessing Jesus Christ, Eph. i . 9, ro, the summing up of all things in Christ, Col. i . 20, God reconciling all things unto Himself in Christ . These passages inspire a hope, but do not sustain a certainty . Paul's shrinking from the disembodied state and longing to be clothed upon at death in 2 Cor . V . 1-8, cannot be regarded as a See also:proof of an See also:interim See also:body See also:prior to and preparatory for the resurrection body . Paul links the human resurrection with a universal renovation (Rom. viii . 19-23) . Paul's eschatology is not See also:free of obscurities and ambiguities; and in the New Testament eschatology generally we are forced to recognize a mixture of inherited Jewish and See also:original Christian elements (see ANTICHRIST) . During the first See also:century of the existence of the See also:Gentile Christian Church, " the hope of the approaching end of the world and the glorious kingdom of Christ " was dominant, although warnings had to be given against doubt and indifference . Redemption was thought of as still future, as the power of the See also:devil had not been broken but rather increased by the First Advent, and the Second Advent was necessary to his See also:complete overthrow . The expectations were often grossly materialistic, as is evidenced by See also:Papias's See also:quotation as the words of the Lord of a See also:group of sayings from the Apocalypse of See also:Baruch, setting forth the amazing fruitfulness of the earth in the Messianic time . The Gnostics rejected this eschatology as in their view the enlightened spirit already possessed immortality . See also:Marcion (Mastics. expected that the Church would be assailed by See also:Anti- christ; a visible return of Christ be did not See also:teach, but he recognized that human history would issue in a separation of the good from the bad . See also:Montanism sought to form a new Christian See also:commonwealth which, separated from the ism. a- world should prepare itself for the descent of the ism . Jerusalem from above, and its See also:establishment in the spot which by the direction of the Spirit had been chosen in See also:Phrygia . While See also:Irenaeus held fast the traditional eschatological beliefs, yet his conception of the Christian salvation as a deification of man tended to weaken their hold on Christian thought . The Alogi 763 in the 2nd century rejected the Apocalypse on See also:account of its See also:chiliasm, its teaching of a visible reign of Christ on earth for a thousand years . Montanism also brought these apocalyptic expectations into discredit in orthodox ecclesiastical circles . The Alexandrian theology strengthened this See also:movement against chiliasm . See also:Clement of See also:Alexandria taught that justice is not merely retributive, that punishment is remedial, that See also:probation continues after death till the final judgment, that Christ and the apostles preached the Gospel in Hades to those who lacked knowledge, but whose See also:heart was right, that a spiritual body will be raised . See also:Origen taught that a germ of the spiritual body is in the present body, and its development depends on the character, that perfect bliss is reached only by stages, that the evil are purified by See also:pain, See also:conscience being symbolized by fire, and that all, even the devil himself, will at last be saved . Both regarded chiliasm with aversion . But in the 5th century there were rejected as heretical (I) " the doctrine of universalism, and the possibility of the redemption of the devil; (2) the doctrine of the complete annihilation of evil; (3) the conception of the penalties of hell as tortures of conscience; (4) the spiritualizing version of the resurrection of the body ; (5) the idea of the continued creation of new worlds " (A . See also:Harnack, History of See also:Dogma, p . 186) . See also:Epiphanius, following See also:Methodius, insisted on the most perfect identity between the resurrection body and the material body; and this belief, enforced in the See also:West by See also:Jerome, soon established itself as alone orthodox . See also:Augustine made experiments on the flesh of a See also:peacock in order to find physical See also:evidence for the doctrine . He held fast to eternal punishment, but allowed the possibility of mitigations . Some believers, he taught, may pass through purgatorial fires; and this See also:middle class may be helped by the sacraments and the See also:alms of the living . " There are many souls not good enough to dispense with this See also:provision, and not bad enough to be benefited by it " (op. cit. v . 233)• This doctrine was sanctioned and See also:developed by See also:Gregory the Great . " After God has changed eternal punishments into temporary, the justified must expiate these temporary penalties for sin in purgatory " (p . 268) . This view was inferred indirectly from Matt. xii . 31, and directly from r Cor. iii . 12-15 . After-wards purgatory took more and more the place of hell, and was subject to the See also:control of the church . As regards the saints, different degrees of blessedness were recognized; they were sup-posed to wait in Hades for the return of Christ, but gradually the belief gained ground, especially in regard to the martyrs, that their souls at once entered Paradise . The See also:primitive Christian eschatology was preserved in the West as it was not in the See also:East, and in times of exceptional See also:distress the expectation of Antichrist emerged again and again . In the middle ages there was an extravagance of speculation on this subject, which may be seen in the last division of See also:Aquinas' Summa Theologiae . He proposes See also:thirty questions on these matters, among which are the following: " whether souls are conducted to heaven or hell immediately after death "; " whrther the See also:limbus of hell is the same as Abraham's bosom "; " whether the sun and moon will be really obscured at the day of judgment "; " whether all the members of the human body will rise with it "; " whether the See also:hair and nails will reappear "; could thought become " more lawless and uncertain" ? While rejectir ; purgatory, Protestantism took over this eschatology . Souls passed at once to heaven or to hell; a doctrine even less adequate to the complex quality of human life . See also:Luther himself looked for the passing lnnrot - testsn away of the present evil world . Socinianism taught a Theology. new spiritual body, an intermediate state in which the soul is near non-existence, an annihilation of the wicked, as Immortality is the See also:gift of God .
See also:Swedenborg discards a physical resurrection, as at death the eyes of men are opened to the spiritual world in which we exist now, and they continue to live essentially as they lived here, until by their affinities they are See also:drawn to heaven or hell
.
The doctrine of eternal punishment has been opposed on many grounds, such as the disproportion between the offence and the penalty, the moral
764
and religious immaturity of the majority of men at death, the diminution of the happiness of heaven involved in the knowledge of the endless suffering of others (See also:Schleiermacher), the defeat of the divine purpose of righteousness and grace that the continued antagonism of any of God's creatures would imply, the dissatisfaction God as Father must feel until His whole family is restored
.
It has been argued that the term " eternal " has reference not to duration of time but quality of being (See also:Maurice) ; but it does seem certain that the writers in the See also:Holy Scriptures who used it did not foresee an end either to the life or to the death to which they applied the term
.
The contention should not be based on the meaning of a single word, but on such broader considerations as have been indicated above
.
The doctrine of conditional immortality taught by Socinianism was accepted by See also:Archbishop See also:Whately, and has been most persistently advocated by See also:Edward See also: |