Online Encyclopedia

Search over 40,000 articles from the original, classic Encyclopedia Britannica, 11th Edition.

MYSTERY (Gr. µw(Trilpcov, from tcuvrm...

Online Encyclopedia
Originally appearing in Volume V19, Page 123 of the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica.
Spread the word: del.icio.us del.icio.us it!

See also:

MYSTERY (Gr. µw(Trilpcov, from tcuvrm, an initiate, µfew, to shut the mouth)  , a See also:general See also:English See also:term for what is See also:secret and excites wonder, derived from the religious sense (see below) . It is not to be confounded with the other old word " See also:mystery," or more properly " mistery," meaning a See also:trade or handicraft (See also:Lat. ministerium, Fr. metier) . For the See also:medieval plays, called mysteries, see See also:DRAMA; they were so called (See also:Skeat) because acted by craftsmen . See also:Greek Mysteries.—It is important to obtain a clear conception of the exact significance of the Greek term 12vvri7Pcov, which is often associated and at times appears synonymous with the words re). r'rl, opyca . We may interpret " mystery " in its See also:original Greek meaning as a " secret " See also:worship, to which only certain specially prepared See also:people—oi pveivres—were admitted after a See also:special See also:period of See also:purification or other preliminary See also:probation, and of which the See also:ritual was so important and perilous that the " See also:catechumen " needed a hierophant or expounder to See also:guide him aright . In the See also:ordinary public worship of the See also:state or the private worship of the See also:household the See also:sacrifice with the See also:prayer was the See also:chief See also:act of the ceremony; in the " mysterion " something other than a sacrifice was of the essence of the rite; something was shown to the eyes of the initiated, the mystery was a See also:Spaµa yvaruc6v, and Spicy and Sp17o-,uoaivp are verbal terms expressive of the mystic act . We have an interesting See also:account given us by Theo Smyrnaeusl of the various elements and moments of the normal mystic ceremony: first is the ica8ap,u6s or preliminary purification; secondly, the rmXeri s Irapdcoots, the mystic communication which probably included some See also:kind of X yos, a sacred exegesis or exhortation; thirdly, the ifro1rreia or the See also:revelation to sight of certain See also:holy things, which is the central point of the whole; fourthly, the crowning with the See also:garland, which is henceforth the badge of the privileged; and finally, that which is the end and See also:object of all this, the happiness that. arises from the friendship or communion with the deity . This exposition is probably applicable to the Greek mysteries in general, though it may well have been derived from his know-ledge of the Eleusinian . We may supplement it by a statement of See also:Lucian's that " no mystery was ever celebrated without dancing " (De saltat . 15), which means that it was in some sense a religious drama, See also:ancient Greek dancing being generally mimetic, and represented some iep6s Aiyos or sacred See also:story as the theme of a mystery-See also:play . Before we approach the problem as to the content of the mysteries, we may naturally raise the question why certaLl 1 De util. math., Herscher, p . 15 .

ancient cults in See also:

Greece were mystic, others open and public . An explanation often offered is that the mystic cults are the Pelasgic or pre-Hellenic and that the conquered populations desired to See also:shroud their religious ceremonies from the profane eyes of the invaders . But we should then expect to find them administered chiefly by slaves and the See also:lower See also:population; on the contrary they are generally in the hands of the noblest families, and the See also:evidence that slaves possessed in any of them the right of See also:initiation is only slight . Nor does the explanation in other respects See also:fit the facts at all . The deities who are worshipped with mystic See also:rites have in most cases Hellenic names and do not all belong to the earliest stratum of Hellenic See also:religion . Besides those of See also:Demeter, by far the most numerous in the Hellenic See also:world, we have See also:record of the mysteries of Ge at Phlye in See also:Attica, of Aglauros and the Charities at See also:Athens, of See also:Hecate at See also:Aegina; a See also:shrine of See also:Artemis Mvaia on the road between See also:Sparta and See also:Arcadia points to a mystic cult of this goddess, and we can infer the existence of a similar worship of See also:Themis . Now these are either various forms of the See also:earth-goddess, or are related closely to her, being See also:powers that we See also:call " chthonian," associated with the world below, the See also:realm of the dead . We may surmise then that the mystic setting of a cult arose in many cases from the dread of the religious miasma which emanated from the nether world and which suggested a See also:prior ritual of purification as necessary to safeguard the See also:person before approaching the holy presence or handling certain holy See also:objects . This would explain the See also:necessity of mysteries in the worship of See also:Dionysus also, the Cretan Zagreus, Trophonius at Lebadeia, See also:Palaemon-See also:Melicertes on the See also:Isthmus of See also:Corinth . They might also be necessary for those who desired communion with the deified ancestor or See also:hero, and thus we hear of the mysteries of Dryops at Asine, of Antinoiis the favourite of See also:Hadrian at See also:Mantineia . Again, where there was See also:hope or promise that the mortal should by communion be able to attain temporarily to divinity, so hazardous an experiment would be safeguarded by special preparation, secrecy and mystic ritual; and this may have been the See also:prime See also:motive of the institution of the See also:Attis-See also:Cybele mystery . (See See also:GREAT See also:MOTHER OF THE GODS.) For the student of See also:Hellenism, the Eleusinian and Orphic ceremonies are of See also:paramount importance; the Samothracian, which vied with these in attractiveness for the later Hellenic world, were not Hellenic in origin, nor whoily hellenized in See also:character, and cannot be considered in an e.rticle of this See also:compass .

As regards the Eleusinia, we are in a better position for the investigation of them than our predecessors were; for the See also:

modern methods of See also:comparative religion and See also:anthropology have at least taught us to ask the right questions and to apply relevant hypotheses; See also:archaeology, the study of vases, excavations on the site, yielding an ever-increasing hoard of See also:inscriptions, have taught us much concerning the See also:external organization of the mysteries, and have shown us the beautiful figures of the deities as they appeared to the See also:eye or to the See also:mental See also:vision of the initiated . As regards the inner content, the secret of the mystic celebration, it is in the highest degree unlikely that Greek inscriptions or See also:art would ever reveal it, the Eleusinian scenes that appear on See also:Attic vases of about the 5th See also:century cannot be supposed to show us the See also:heart of the mystery, for such sacrilegious rashness would be dangerous for the See also:vase-painter . If we are to discover it, we must turn to the ancient See also:literary records . These must be handled with extreme caution and a more careful See also:scrutiny than is often applied . We must not expect full enlightenment from the See also:Pagan writers, who convey to us indeed the See also:poetry and the glow of this fascinating ritual, and who attest the deep and purifying See also:influence that it exercised upon the religious temperament, but who are not likely to tell us more . It is to the See also:Christian Fathers we must turn for more See also:esoteric knowledge, for they would be withheld by no See also:scruple from revealing what they knew . But we cannot always believe that they knew much, for only those who, like See also:Clement and See also:Arnobius, had been Pagans in their youth, could ever have been initiated . Many of them uncritically confuse in the same context and in one sweeping verdictof condemnation Orphic, Phrygian-Sabazian and Attis-Mysteries with the Eleusinian; and we ought not too lightly to infer that these were actually confused and blended at See also:Eleusis . We must also he on our guard against supposing that when Pagan or Christian writers refer vaguely to " mysteria," they always have the Eleusinian in their mind . The questions that the See also:critical See also:analysis of all the evidence may hope to solve are mainly these: (a) What do we know or what can we infer concerning the See also:personality of the deities to whom the Eleusinian mysteries were originally consecrated, and were new figures admitted at a later period ? (b) When was the mystery taken over by Athens and opened to all Hellas, and what was the state-organization provided ? (c) What was the inner significance, essential content or purport of the Eleusinia, and what was the source of their great influence on Hellas ?

(d) Can we attribute any ethical value to them, and did they strongly impress the popular belief in See also:

immortality ? Limits of space allow us only to adumbrate the results that See also:research on the lines of these questions has hitherto yielded . The paramount divine personalities of the mystery were in the earliest period of which we have literary record, the mother and the daughter, Demeter and Kore, the latter being never styled Persephone in the See also:official See also:language of Eleusis; while the third figure, the See also:god of the lower world known by the euphemistic names of See also:Pluto (Plouton) and at one See also:time Eubouleus, the ravisher and the See also:husband, is an See also:accessory personage, comparatively in the background . This is the conclusion naturally See also:drawn from the Homeric hymn to Demeter, a See also:composition of great ritualistic value, probably of the 7th century B.C., which describes the See also:abduction of the daughter, the sorrow and See also:search of the mother, her sitting by the sacred well, the drinking of the KimeWV or sacred See also:cup and the See also:legend of the See also:pomegranate . An ancient hymn of Pamphos, from which See also:Pausanias freely quotes and which he regards, as genuine,' appears to have told much the same story in much the same way . As far as we can say, then, the mother and daughter were there in See also:possession at the very beginning . The other pair of divinities known as 6 9e6s Bea, that appear in a 5th-century inscription and on two dedicatory reliefs found at Eleusis, have been supposed to descend from an aboriginal period of Eleusinian religion when deities were nameless, and when a peaceful pair of earth-divinities, male and See also:female, were worshipped by the rustic community, before the earth-goddess had pluralized herself as Demeter and Kore, and before the story of the madre dolorosa and the lost daughter had arisen ? But for various reasons the contrary view is more probable, that 6 Oebs and i1 Bea are later cult-titles of the married pair Pluto-Cora (Plouton-Kore), the See also:personal names being omitted from that feeling of reverential shyness which was specially timid in regard to the sacred names of the deities of the underworld . And it is a fairly See also:familiar phenomenon in Greek religion that two See also:separate titles of the same divinity engender two distinct cults . The question as to the See also:part played by Dionysus in the Eleusinia is important . Some scholars, like M . Foucart, have supposed that he belonged from the beginning to the inner circle of the mystery; others that he forced his way in at a somewhat later period owing to the great influence of the Orphic sects who captured the stronghold of Attic religion and engrafted the Orphic-Sabazian lep6r Xlyos, the story of the incestuous See also:union of Dionysus-See also:Sabazius with Demeter-Kore, and of the See also:death and rendering of Zagreus, upon the See also:primitive Eleusinian faith .

A saner and more careful See also:

criticism rejects this view . There is no genuine trace discovered as yet in the inner circle of the mysteries of any characteristically Orphic See also:doctrine; the names of Zagreus and Phanes are nowhere heard, the legend of Zagreus and the death of Dionysus are not known, to have been mentioned there . Nor is there any See also:print within or in the precincts of the TeXeo'Ti7Piov: the See also:hall of the Mu:See also:rat, of the footsteps of the Phrygian deities, Cybele, Attis, Sabazius . ' i . 38, 3 ; i . 39, I . 2 See Dittenberger, Sylloge, 13; Corp. inscr. att . 2, 1620 c, 3, 1109; Ephem. archaiol . (1886), rip . 3; Heberdey in Festschrift See also:fur Benndorf, p . 3, Taf . 4; Von Prott in Athen .

Mittheil . (1899), p . 262 . The exact relation of Dionysus to the mysteries involves the aaapxal or tithe-offerings pf See also:

corn to Eleusis,2 record the far-sighted policy of Periclean Athens, her determination to find a religious support for her See also:hegemony . At least from the 5th century onwards, the external See also:control and all questions of the organization of the mysteries were in the hands of the Athenian state, the See also:rule holding in Attica as elsewhere in Hellas that the state was supreme over the See also:Church . The See also:head of the general management was the See also:king-See also:archon (archon-basileus) who with his paredros and the four " epimeletai " formed a general See also:committee of supervision, and matters of importance connected with the ritual were decided by the See also:Boule or See also:Ecclesia . But the claim of Eleusis as the religious See also:metropolis was not ignored . The chief of the two priestly families, in whose hands See also:lay the mystic celebration itself and the formal right of See also:admission, was the Eleusinian " gens " of the Eumolpidae; it was to their ancestor that Demeter had entrusted her 6pyca, and the recognition of their claims maintained the principle of apostolic See also:succession.' To them belonged the hierophant (tepo46vrrs), the high See also:priest of the Eleusinia, whose See also:function alone it was to " reveal the orgies," to show the sacred things, and who alone—or perhaps with his See also:consort-priestess—could penetrate into the innermost shrine in the hall; an impressive figure, so sacred in person that no one could address him by his personal name, and See also:bound, at one period at least, by a rule of See also:celibacy . We hear also of two " hierophantides," female attendants on the older and younger goddesses . In fact, while the male priest predominates in this ritual, the See also:women play a prominent part: as we should expect, considering that the See also:sister-festival of the Thesmophoria was wholly in their hands . The other old priestly See also:family was that of the " Kerykes," to whom the Sgbovxoc belonged, " the holder of the See also:torch," the official second in See also:rank to the lepo4avrri . It is uncertain whether this family was of Eleusinian origin; and in the 4th century it seems to have died out, and the See also:office of the Sgboirxos passed into the hands of the Lycomidae, a priestly family of Phlye, suspected of being devotees of Orphism .

Turning now to the celebration itself, we can only See also:

sketch the more salient features here . On the 13th of Boedromion, the Attic See also:month corresponding roughly to our See also:September, the See also:Ephebi (q.v.) marched out to Eleusis, and returned to Athens the next See also:day bringing with them the " holy- things " (feat) to the " Eleusinion " in the See also:city; these teat probably included small images of the goddesses . The 16th was the day of the ayvpµos, the gathering of the catechumens, when they met to hear the address of the hierophant, called the Irpbpproncs . This was no See also:sermon, but a See also:proclamation bidding those who were disqualified or for some See also:reason unworthy of initiation to depart . The legally qualified were all Hellenes and subsequently all See also:Romans above a certain—very youthful—limit of See also:age, women, and as it appears even slaves; barbarians, and those uncleansed of some notorious See also:guilt, such as See also:homicide, were disqualified . We are sure that there was no dogmatic test, nor would time allow of any searching moral scrutiny, and only the Samothracian rites, in this respect unique in the world of classical religion, possessed a See also:system of See also:confessional . The hierophant appealed to the See also:conscience of the multitude; but we are not altogether sure of the terms of his proclamation, which can only be approximately restored from See also:late Pagan and See also:early Christian writers . We know that he demanded of each See also:candidate that he should be " of intelligible speech (i.e. an Hellene) and pure of See also:hand "; and he catechized him as to his See also:condition of ritualistic purity—the See also:food he had eaten or abstained from . It appears also from See also:Libanius that in the later period at least he solemnly proclaimed that the catechumen should be " pure of soul," 3 and this spiritual conception of holiness had arisen already in the earlier periods of Greek religious thought . On the other hand we must See also:bear in mind the criticism that See also:Diogenes is said to have passed upon the Eleusinia, that many See also:bad characters were admitted to communion, thereby securing a promise of higher happiness than an uninitiated See also:Epaminondas could aspire to . An essential preliminary was purification and See also:lustration, and z Dittenberger, Sylloge, 13 .. 2 Or .

Corinth, iv . 356 . question as to the divine personage called Iacchus; who and what was Iacchus ? See also:

Strabo (p . 468), who is a poor authority on such matters, describes him as " the daemon of Demeter, the founder of the See also:leader of the mysteries." More important is it to See also:note that " Iacchus " is unknown to the author of the Homeric hymn, and that the first literary See also:notice of him occurs in the well-known passage of See also:Herodotus (viii . 65), who describes the procession of the mystae as moving along the sacred way from Athens to Eleusis and as raising the cry "Iaaxe . We find Iacchus the theme of a glowing invocation in an Aristophanic See also:Ode (Frogs, 324-398), and described as a beautiful " See also:young god "; but he is first explicitly identified with Dionysus in the beautiful ode of See also:Sophocles' See also:Antigone (1119); and that this was in See also:accord with the popular ritualistic See also:lore is proved by the statement of the scholiast on See also:Aristophanes (Frogs, 482) that the people at the Lenaea, the See also:winter-festival of Dionysus, responded to the command of " Invoke the god!" with the invocation " See also:Hail, Iacchus, son of See also:Semele, See also:thou giver of See also:wealth!" We are sure, then, that in the high See also:tide of the Attic religious See also:history Iacchus was the youthful Dionysus, a name of the great god See also:peculiar to Attic cult; and this is all that here concerns us to know . We can now See also:answer the question raised above . This youthful Attic Dionysus has his See also:home at Athens; he accompanies his votaries along the sacred way, filling their souls with the exaltation and See also:ecstasy of the Dionysiac spirit; but at Eleusis he had no See also:temple, See also:altar or abiding home; he comes as a visitor and departs . His See also:image may have been carried into the Hall of the Mysteries, but whether it played any part there in a See also:passion-play we do not know . That he was a See also:primary figure of the essential mystery is hard to believe, for we find no traces of his name in the other Greek communities that at an early period had instituted mysteries on the Eleusinian See also:model . Apart from Iacchus, Dionysus in his own name was powerful enough at Eleusis as in most other localities .

And the votaries carried with them no doubt into the hall the Bacchic exaltation of the Iacchus procession and the nightly revel with the god that preceded the full initiation; many of them also may have belonged to the private Dionysiac sects and might be tempted to read a Dionysiac significance into much that was presented to them . But all this is conjecture . The See also:

interpretation of what was shown would naturally See also:change somewhat with the changing sentiment of the ages; but the mother and the daughter, the stately and beautiful figures presented to us by the author of the homeric hymn, who says no word of Dionysus, are still found reigning paramount and supreme at Eleusis just before the See also:Gothic invasion in the latter days of Paganism . See also:Triptolemus the apostle of corn-culture, Eubouleus—originally a euphemistic name of the god of the under-world, " the giver of See also:good counsel," conveying a hint of his oracular functions—these are accessory figures of Eleusinian cult and See also:mythology that may have played some part in the great mystic drama that was enacted in the hall . The development and organization of the Eleusinia may now be briefly sketched . The legends concerning the initiation of Heracles and the Dioscuri preserve the record of the time when the mysteries were closed against all strangers, and were the See also:privilege of the Eleusinians alone . Now the Homeric hymn in its obvious See also:appeal to the whole of the Greek world to avail themselves of these mysteries gives us to suppose that they had already been thrown open to Hellas; and this momentous change, abolishing the old See also:gentile barriers, may have naturally coincided with, or have resulted from, the See also:fusion of Eleusis and Athens, an event of equal importance for politics and religion which we may See also:place in the prehistoric period . The reign of See also:Peisistratus was an era of architectural activity at Eleusis; but the construction of the AVvTCKbc orKOS was one of the achievements of the Periclean See also:administration . Two inscriptions, containing decrees passed during the supremacy of See also:Pericles, the one proclaiming a holy truce of three months for the votaries that came from any Greek community,' the other bidding the subject See also:allies and inviting the See also:independent states to send ' Corp. inscr. all. i . 1 . after the See also:assembly the " mystae " went to the See also:sea-See also:shore (tXa& archaeological evidence that has been supposed to support the pia-rat) and purified themselves with sea-See also:water, and probably with sprinkling of pigs' See also:blood, a See also:common cathartic See also:medium . After their return from the sea, a sacrifice of some kind was offered as an essential condition of pawls, but whether as a See also:sacrament or a See also:gift-offering to the goddesses it is impossible to determine .

On the loth of Boedromion the great procession started along the sacred way bearing the " See also:

fair young god " Iacchus; and as they visited many shrines by the way the See also:march must have continued See also:long after sunset, so that the loth is some-times spoken of as the day of the See also:exodus of Iacchus . On the way each wore a See also:saffron See also:band as an See also:amulet; and the ceremonious reviling to which the " mystai " were subjected as they crossed the See also:bridge of the Cephissus answered the same purpose of averting the evil eye . Upon the arrival at Eleusis, on the same See also:night or on the following, they celebrated a midnight revel under the stars with Iacchus, which Aristophanes glowingly describes . The question of supreme See also:interest now arises: What was the mystic ceremony in the hall? what was said and what was done ? We can distinguish two grades in the celebration; the greater was the See also:ram and E7r07rrcxa, the full and satisfying celebration, to which only those were admitted who had passed the lesser See also:stage at least a See also:year before . As regards the actual ritual in the hall of the mystae, much remains uncertain in spite of the unwearying efforts of many generations of scholars to construct a reasonable statement out of fragments of often doubtful evidence . We are certain at least that something was acted there in a religious drama or passion-play, the revelation was partly-a See also:pageant of holy figures; the accusations against See also:Aeschylus and See also:Alcibiades would suffice to prove this; and See also:Porphyry speaks of the hierophant and the 5 ouxos acting divine parts . What the subject of this drama was may he gathered partly from the words of Clement—" Deo (Demeter) and Kore became the personages of a mystic drama, and Eleusis with its 50ovXor celebrates the wandering, the abduction and the sorrow " (Protrept., p . 12 See also:Potter), partly from See also:Psyche's appeal to Demeter in See also:Apuleius (llletamorph . 6)—" by the unspoken secrets of the mystic chests, the winged chariots of thy See also:dragon-ministers, the bridal descent of See also:Proserpine [Persephone], the torch-lit wanderings to find thy daughter and all the other mysteries that the shrine of Attic Eleusis shrouds in secret." We may believe then that the great myth of the mother's sorrow, the loss and the partial recovery of her beloved was part of the Eleusinian passion-play . Did it also include a iepdr yayos ? We should naturally expect that the sacred story acted in the mystic pageant would See also:close with the See also:scene of reconciliation, such as a holy See also:marriage of the god and the goddess .

But the evidence that this was so is mainly indirect, apart from a doubtful passage in Asterius, a writer of questionable authority in the 4th century A.D . (Econom. See also:

martyr. p . 194, See also:Combe) . At any See also:rate, if a holy marriage formed part of the passion-play, it may well have been acted with solemnity and delicacy . We have no reason to believe that even to a modern See also:taste any part of the ritual would appear coarse or obscene; even Clement, who brings a vague See also:charge of See also:obscenity against all mysteries in general, does not try to substantiate it in regard to the Eleusinia, and we hear from another Christian writer of the scrupulous purity of the hierophant . It would be interesting to know if the See also:birth of a holy See also:child, a babe Iacchus, for example, was a motive of the mystic drama . The question seems at first sight to be decided by a definite statement of See also:Hippolytus (Philosoph . 5, 8), that at a certain moment in the mysteries the hierophant cried aloud: " The See also:lady-goddess Brimo has See also:borne Brimos the holy child." But a careful See also:consideration of the context almost destroys the value of his authority . For he does not pretend to be a first-hand See also:witness, but admits that he is See also:drawing from Gnostic See also:sources, and he goes on at once to speak of Attis and his self-See also:mutilation . The See also:formula may then refer to the Sabazian-Phrygian mystery, which the Gnostics with their usual spirit of religious See also:syncretism would have no scruple in identifying with the Eleusinian . And the statement of Hippolytus is deceptive . Finally, we must not suppose that there could be any very elaborate scenic arrangements in the hall for the See also:representation of See also:Paradise and the Inferno, whereby the rewards of the faithful and the punishments of the damned might be impressively brought home to the mystae .

The excavations on the site have proved that the See also:

building was without substructures or under-ground passages . A large number of inscriptions See also:present us with elaborate accounts of Eleusinian See also:expenditure; but there is no See also:item for scenic expenses or See also:painting . We are led to suppose that the pageant-play produced its effect by means of gorgeous raiment, torches and stately figures . But the mystic See also:action included more than the pageant-play . The hierophant revealed certain holy objects to the eyes of the assembly . There is reason to suppose that these included certain primitive idols of the goddesses of immemorial sanctity; and, if we accept a statement of Hippolytus (loc. cit.) we must believe that the epoptae were also shown " that great and marvellous mystery of perfect revelation, a cut corn-stalk." The value of this definite assertion, which appears to be an explicit revelation of the secret, would be very great, if we could See also:trust it; but unfortunately it occurs in the same suspicious context as the Brimo-Brimos formula, and we again suspect the same uncritical confusion of Eleusinian with Phrygian ritual, for we know that Attis himself was identified in his mysteries with the " reaped corn," the vraXvs aµrlros, almost the very phrase used by Hippolytus . Only, it is in the highest degree probable, whether Hippolytus knew anything or not, that a corn-token was shown among the sacred things of a mystery which possessed an original agrarian significance and was intended partly to consecrate and to See also:foster the agricultural See also:life . But to say this is by no means the same as to admit the view of Lenormanti and Dr Jevons2 that the Eleusinians worshipped the actual corn, or revered it as a See also:clan-totem . For of See also:direct corn-worship or of corn-See also:totemism there is no trace either at Eleusis or elsewhere in Greece . Among the See also:Spes €va or " things done " may we also include a See also:solemn sacrament, the celebration of a holy communion, in which the votary was See also: