Online Encyclopedia

Search over 40,000 articles from the original, classic Encyclopedia Britannica, 11th Edition.

TALMUD

Online Encyclopedia
Originally appearing in Volume V26, Page 386 of the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica.
Spread the word: del.icio.us del.icio.us it!

TALMUD  , the See also:

great Rabbinical See also:thesaurus which See also:grew up during the first four or six centuries of the See also:Christian Era, and, with the Old Testament, became the " See also:Bible " of the See also:Jews, and the See also:chief subject of their subsequent See also:literary activity . 1 . Contents.—The Talmud (See also:Hebrew " teaching, learning ") consists of the Mishnah (Heb . " [oral] repetition, teaching "), a systematic collection of religious-legal decisions developing the See also:laws of the Old Testament, and the Gemara (Aramaic " completion, decision," or perhaps also " teaching "), supplementary material, legal and otherwise.' The whole was in two great recensions, Palestinian and Babylonian . Other material related to the Mishnah is preserved in the Tosephta (See also:Aram . " addition ") and the Midrashim, and since all these, together with the Targziinim, represent the orthodox Rabbinical literature connecting the Old Testament with See also:medieval and See also:modern Judaism, the reader should also consult the articles JEWS (parts ii. and iii.), See also:MIDRASH, See also:TARGUM, and for more detailed and See also:critical treatment the references given to the Jewish Encyclopedia . ' Mishnah stands in contrast to Miqra (" See also:reading, scripture "); its Aram. See also:equivalent is Mallznitha, from tend, " to repeat,' whence the appellation Tannd, " teacher " (§ 3 below) . These and the terms Gemara, Talmud, &c., are more fully explained in H . L . Strack's invaluable Einleilung in den Talmud (See also:Leipzig, '1908), pp . 2 sqq . The Mishnah is a more or less careful arrangement of the extant Oral See also:Law (see § 2) .

It forms the See also:

foundation of the Gemara, and is divided into six Seddrim or Orders, each containing a number of MassektOth (" weavings," cf. the See also:etymology of " See also:text ") or Tractates . These are subdivided into Peragim (" sections ") or chapters, and these again into paragraphs or sentences . I . Zera`See also:im (" seeds "), the first See also:Order, on See also:agriculture, is introduced by (I) Berakoth (" blessings "), on daily and other prayers and blessings . (2) Pe'ah (" corner "), deals with Lev. xix . 9 seq., See also:xxiii . 22; Deut. See also:xxiv . 19-22, and the rights of the poor . (3) Demai, or rather Dammai (" doubtful "), on doubtful cases See also:relating to the See also:tithing of See also:fruit offerings . (4) Kil'ayim (" of two sorts "), on for-bidden mixtures (Lev. xix . 19; Deut. xxii . 9-II) .

(5) Shebi`ith (" seventh "), on the sabbatical See also:

year (Ex. xxiii . I I ; Lev. See also:xxv . 1-8; Deut. xv. i sqq.) . (6) Terume-th (" heave offerings "), on the laws in Num. xviii . 8 sqq., 25 seq . ; Deut. xviii . 4 . (7) Ma`asroth (" See also:tithes ") or Ma`aser Ri'shon (" first tithe "), with reference to the See also:Levites, Num. xviii . 21-24 . (8) Ma'aser Sheni (" second tithe "), with reference to the tithe eaten at See also:Jerusalem, Deut. xiv . 22-26 . (9) Hallah (" cake "), on Num. xv .

18-21 . (to) 'Orlah (" foreskin " [of trees]), on Lev. xix . 23-25 . (II) Bikkiitrim (" first-fruits "), on Ex. xxiii . 19; Deut. See also:

xxvi. i sqq . The See also:fourth See also:chapter of this See also:treatise, printed in most See also:editions, is properly a Baraitha . II . Mo ed (" festival ") . (I) Shabbath, on the See also:Sabbath as a See also:day of See also:rest, Ex. xx. to, xxiii . 12; Deut. v . 14, &c . (useful edition by Strack, 1890) .

(2) `Erubin (" mixtures " or amalgamations), on legitimate methods of avoiding inconvenient restrictions on the Sabbath . (3) Pesahim (" passovers "—sacrifices and meals), on Ex. xii, xiii . 6-8, xxiii . 15; Lev. xxiii . 5 sqq . ; Num. See also:

xxviii. i6 sqq . ; Deut. xvi. t sqq., &c . (4) Shegalim (" shekels "), on the See also:poll tax (Ex. See also:xxx . 12 sqq . ; Neb. x . 33) . (5) Yonia (Aram .

" the day "), or Kippurim (" See also:

atonement "), or Y. ha-k . (" the day of atonement "), on Lev. xvi., xxiii . 26-32 (useful edition by H . L . Strack, Leipzig, 1904) . (6) Sukkah or Sukkoth (" See also:booth[s] "), on Lev. xxiii . 34 sqq . ; Num . See also:xxix . 12 sqq.; Deut. xvi . 13-16 . (7) Besah (" See also:egg," the opening word) or Yom tob (" See also:good [i.e. feast] day "), See also:general rules for feast-days .

(8) Rosh ha-Shanah (" New Year festival "), on the services, the See also:

calendar, and more particularly on the first of the Seventh See also:Month (cf . Num. x. to, xxviii. i t sqq., &c.) . (9) Ta'anith or Ta'aniyyolh, i.e . " fast[s]," See also:special observances relating thereunto; in particular to public fasts appointed in See also:time of drought . (to) Megillah, " See also:roll " (of See also:Esther), the reading of it at See also:Purim, &c . (II) Mc'ed Titan (" the small M," to distinguish it from the name of this order), or Mashkin (the first word), regulations for the intermediate festivals at See also:Passover and See also:Tabernacles . (12) Hagigah (" festival "), on the three See also:principal festivals, Deut. xvi . 16, the See also:duty of pilgrims and the defilements to be avoided (transl. from Bab . Talm. by A . W . Streane, Camb., 1891) . xxx .

(4) Nazir (" Nazirite "), on Num. vi . (5) Giftin (" documents "), on See also:

divorce and separation . (6) SOtah (" the faithless woman "), on Num. v . 11-31 . (7) Qiddushin (" sanctifications " of See also:marriage), on the contraction of legal marriage . IV . Nezigin (" See also:damages "), also known as Yeshu`oth (" deeds of help ") . (I) Baba See also:gamma (Aram . " the first See also:gate "), on injuries and See also:compensation; See also:civil law . (2) B . Mesi a (Aram . " the See also:middle gate "), on sales, leases, lost See also:property .

(3) B . See also:

Baths (Aram . " the last gate "), on real See also:estate, See also:succession, &c . (4) Sanhedrin (avvESpwv), on See also:procedure and criminal law . (5) Makkoth, "blows," on the number to be inflicted (Deut. xxv . 1-3) and for what offence, &c . (6) Shebis`oth (" oaths "), on Lev. v . 4 sqq . (7) 'Eduyyolh, " testimonies," viz. of later teachers regarding their predecessors, on the See also:schools of See also:Hillel and See also:Shammai, 'Aqiba, &c., important for the problem of the literary growth of the Mishnah . (8) ',Ibodah 'See also:Zara (" idolatrous See also:worship "), regulations in reference to See also:heathen See also:idolatry (useful edition with Germ. transl. by Strack, 1909; and including that of the Gemara by F . C . See also:Ewald, See also:Nuremberg, 1856) .

(9) 'AbOth or Pirqe A . (" sayings of the fathers "), a famous collection of See also:

maxims; the See also:sixth chapter on " the See also:possession of the law " does not properly,belong to the Mishnah (ed. with transl. by C . See also:Taylor, Camb . 1897, and in See also:German by H . L . Strack, 1901) . (lo) Horayolh (" decisions "), on judicial and other errors (Lev. iv. i sqq.) . V . Q6dd-shim (" See also:holy things ") . (I) Zebahim (" sacrifices "), or shehi(See also:ath gbdashim (" the slaughter of holy things "), on the sacrificial laws, &c . (2) Menahoth (" See also:meat-offerings "), on Lev. ii . 5, II-13, vi .

7-16, xiv . 10-20, &c . (3) Hullin or Shehilath H . (" [the slaughter of] See also:

common things "), on non-sacrificial meat: (a) Bekoroth (" first-See also:born "), on firstlings (Ex. xiii . Iz seq.; Lev. See also:xxvii . 26 seq . ; Num. viii . 16-18, xviii . I5-17;' Deut. xv . 19 sqq.) . (5) 'Arakin (" valuations " for See also:ransom, &c.), on Lev. xxv . 15-28, 29 sqq., xxvii .

2 sqq., 28 seq . (6) Temurah (" See also:

exchange of dedicated animals), cf . Lev. xxvii. to, 33 . (7) See also:Ker-ithoth (" cutting off "), on See also:excommunication, &c . (8) Me`ilah (" trespass "), on Lev. v . 15 sqq.; Num. v . 6-8 . (9) Tamid, on the " continual or perpetual (daily' burnt offering)," Ex. xxix . 38—42; Num. xxviii . 2–8 . (1o) Middoth (" See also:measures "), an important tractate on the See also:temple (measurements, See also:gates, halls, &c.) . (II) Qinnim (" nests "), on sacrifices of doves by the poor (cf .

Lev. i . 14–17, v . I sqq., xii . 8) . VI . Tohoroth or Teh., " purifications," a See also:

euphemism for things which are ritually or ceremonially " unclean." (1) Kelim (" vessels "), their uncleanness (cf . Lev. xi . 32 sqq . ; Num. xix . 14 sqq., xxxi . 20 sqq.) . (2) Ohaloth (" tents "), on defilement through a See also:corpse (Num. xix .

14–20), &c . (3) Nega'im (" plagues," i.e. leprosy), on Lev. seq . (4) See also:

Farah (the [red] " See also:heifer "), on Num. xix . (5) Teharoth (euphemism for impurities), on See also:minor defilements . (6) Migwa-'oth (See also:ritual baths), bathing for the defiled (cf . Lev. xiv . 8, xv . 5 sqq.; Num. xxxi . 23; also See also:Mark vii . 4) . (7) Niddah (See also:female " impurity "), on Lev. xv . 19–33 .

(8) Makshirin (" predisposing "), or Mashgin (" liquids "), on defilement caused by wet unclean things (cf . Lev. xi . 34, 37 seq.) . (9) Zabim (" those with a See also:

discharge "), on Lev. xv . (to) Tebul Yom (" immersed for [or on] the day "), on those who have taken a ritual See also:bath and must wait until sunset before becoming ritually pure (see Lev. xv . 5, xxii . 6 seq ; Num. xix . 19) . (II) Yaddyim, " hands, ' their See also:purification (cf . Matt. xv . 2, 20; Mark vii . 2–4, &c.) .

(12) Ugrin (' stems "), on the relation between fruit and the stems and stalks as regards defilement, &c . To Order IV. the Babylonian recension of the Talmud adds seven See also:

treatises, which are of later origin and are regarded as more or less extra-canonical . (I) Aboth de See also:Rabbi Nathan, an expansion of IV . 9, attributed to a second-See also:century Rabbi, but See also:post-Talmudic (ed . S . Schechter, 1887) . (2) Sopherim (" See also:scribes "), on the See also:writing of the scrolls of the See also:Pentateuch, grammatical (Massoretic) rules, and (a later addition) on the See also:liturgy (ed . J . See also:Muller, Leipzig, 1878) . (3) See also:Ebel Rabbathi (" great weeping "), or, euphemistically, Semahoth C' joys "), on See also:mourning customsand rules . (4) Kallah (" betrothed, See also:bride "), on chastity in marriage, &c . Derek Ere .

(5) Rabbah, and (6) See also:

Zula, a " large " and a " small " treatise on various rules of " conduct " and social See also:life . (7) Pereq ha-Shalom, a " chapter on See also:peace " (peacefulness) . In addition to these seven, other small Talmudic treatises are also reckoned (edited by R . Kirchheim, See also:Frankfort-on-See also:Main, 185o) . These See also:deal with (I) the writing of the rolls of the Law; (2) Mezuzah (Dent. vi . 9, xi . 20); (3) Tephillin (prayers, phylacteries) ; (4) the fringes (Num. xv . 38) ; (5) slaves; (6) the See also:Samaritans (see J . A . See also:Montgomery, The Samaritans, pp . 196 sqq.); and (7) proselytes . The Mishnah itself contains 63 tractates, or, since IV .

1–3 originally formed one (called Nezigin) and IV . 4, 5 were See also:

united, 6o . The number is also given as 70 (cf . 2 Esd. xiv . 44–46), perhaps by including the seven smaller treatises appended to IV . There are 523 chapters (or 525, see I . If, IV . 9) . 2 . The Origin of the Mishnah.—A careful distinction was See also:drawn between the Written Law, the See also:Mosaic Torah, and the rest of the Scriptures (z?+?;m mia), and the Oral Law, or Torah by Mouth (n;'n ntra) . The origin of the latter, which has become codified in the Mishnah, has often been discussed . It was supposed that it had been handed down by See also:Ezra; that it was indebted to See also:Joshua, See also:David or See also:Solomon; that it was as old as See also:Moses, to whom it had been communicated orally or in writing, See also:complete or in its essence .

The traditional view is well illustrated in the words ascribed to R . See also:

Simeon Lakish, 3rd century A.D.:1 " What is that which is written, ' I will give thee the tables of See also:stone, and the Law and the Commandment, which I have written, that See also:thou mayest See also:teach them (Ex. xxiv . 12) ' ? ` Tables,' these are the Ten Words (the See also:Decalogue) ; the ` Law ' is the Scripture; ` and the commandment,' that is the Mishnah: ' which I have written,' these are the Prophets and Writings (i.e . The Hagiographa), ` to teach them,' that is the Gemara—thus instructing us that all these were given to Moses from See also:Sinai." Literary and See also:historical See also:criticism places the discussion on another basis when it treats the Mosaic Torah in its See also:present See also:form as a post-exilic compilation (about 5th century a.c.) from See also:sources differing in date, origin and See also:history . There is no a priori See also:reason why other legal enactments should not have been current when the compilation was first made: the Pentateuchal legislation is incomplete, and covers only a small See also:part of the affairs of life in which legal decisions ' For the See also:sake of convenience See also:Ben (" son ") and Rabbi are, as usual, abbreviated to b. and R . For the See also:quotation which follows, see Oesterley and See also:Box, The See also:Religion and Worship of the See also:Synagogue (See also:London, 1907) p . 51; and, on the subject, S . Schechter, Studies in Judaism (London, 1896), ch. vii.—" the history of Jewish tradition "; E . See also:Weber, Judische Theologie (Leipzig, 1897), pp . 91 seq. and 130 sqq . ; Strack, op. cit., p .

8 seq.; W . Bousset, Relig. d . Judentums (See also:

Berlin, 1906), pp . 176 sqq., and See also:Jew . Ency., iv . 423 sqq . ; see also G . B . See also:Gray's See also:art . " Law Literature " in the Ency . Bib.might be needed . There must have been a large See also:body of usage to which Jewish society subscribed; customary usage is one of the most binding of laws even among modern See also:Oriental communities where laws in writing are unknown, and one of the most interesting features is the persistence in the See also:East of closely-related forms and principles of See also:custom from the See also:oldest times to the present day .

Laws must be adjusted from time to time to meet changing needs, and new necessities naturally arose in the See also:

Greek and See also:Roman See also:period for which the older codes and usages made no See also:provision . Much in the same way as Roman law was derived from the Twelve Tables, the Jewish written laws were used as the authority for subsequent modifications, and the continuity of the religious-legal See also:system was secured by a skilful treatment of old precedents ? In the See also:article MIDRASH it will be seen that new teaching could justify itself by a re-See also:interpretation of the old writings, and that the traditions of former authoritative figures could become the framework of a teaching considerably later than their See also:age . It is probable that this See also:process was largely an unconscious one; and even if conscious, the See also:analogy of the conventional " legal fiction " and the usual anxiety to avoid the See also:appearance of novelty is enough to show that it is not to be condemned . By the help of a tradition —a " haggadic " or " halakic " Midrash (q.v . § 1)—contemporary custom or ideals could appear to have See also:ancient precedents, or by means of an exegetical process they could be directly connected with old See also:models . In the Old Testament many laws in the Mosaic legislation are certainly post-Mosaic and the value of not a few narratives lies, not in their historical or See also:biographical See also:information, but in their treatment of law, ritual, custom, belief, &c . Later developments are exemplified in the pseud-epigraphical literature, notably in the See also:Book of See also:Jubilees, and when we reach the Mishnah and Talmud, we have only the first of a new See also:series of stages which, it may be said, culminate in the 16th-century Shulhan `Aruk, the great compendium of the then existing written and oral law . Thus, the problem of the origin or antiquity of the unwritten Oral Law, a living and fluid thing, lies outside the See also:scope of criticism; of greater utility is the study of the particular forms the laws have taken in the written sources which from time to time embody the ever-changing See also:legacy of the past . The course of development between the recognition of the supremacy of the Pentateuch and the actual writing down of the Mishnah and Gemara can be traced only in broad lines . It is known that a great See also:mass of oral tradition was current, and there are a number of See also:early references to written collections, especially of haggadah . On the other See also:hand, certain references indicate that there was a strong opposition to writing down the Oral Law .

It is possible, therefore, that written See also:

works were in circulation among the learned, and that these contained varying interpretations which were likely to injure efforts to maintain a See also:uniform Judaism . See also:Philo speaks of ,uvpta o'eypa.ba WBi7 Kol voµcµa (ed . Mangey, ii . 629), and the oral See also:esoteric traditions of the See also:Pharisees are attested by See also:Josephus (xiii . It), 6, cf . 16, 2); cf. in the New Testament, Matt. xv . 1–9, Mark vii . 8, &c.; and the bevrepc ens " repetitions " (cf. the See also:term Mishnah) of the Christian Fathers . For the written collections, see Strack, op. cit., pp. io sqq.; J . Theodor, Jew . Ency., viii . 552; J .

Z . Lauterbach, ib., p . 614; W . Bacher, ib., xii . 19; S . Schechter, See also:

Hastings' See also:Diet . Bible, v . 62; and art . MIDRASH, § 5, in this See also:work . The theory of an esoteric tradition is distinctly represented in 2 Esdras xiv., where Moses receives words which were not to be published, and Ezra re-writes seventy books which were to be delivered to the See also:wise men of his See also:people . Also the Book of Jubilees knows of See also:secret written traditions containing regulations regarding sacrifices, &c., and See also:Jacob hands over " all his books and the books of his fathers to See also:Levi his son that he might preserve them and renew them for his See also:children (i.e. the priestly See also:caste) unto this day " (xlv . 16) .

3 . Growth of the Mishnah and Gemara.—According to the traditional view the See also:

canon of the Old Testament closed with the work of Ezra . He was followed by the Sopherim, " scribes " (or the Men of the great Synagogue), to the Maccabaean age, and these again by the " Pairs " (zugoth, Gr . 'uyov), the reputed heads of the Sanhedrin, down to the Herodian age (150–30 B.C.) . The last culminate in Hillel (q.v.) and Shammai, the founders of two great See also:rival schools, and to this famous pair the work 2 See W . R . See also:Smith, Old Test, in the Jewish See also:Church, p . 51 seq., I6o . of See also:collecting hdldkoth (" legal decisions ") has been ascribed . The ensuing period of the Tannd'im, " teachers " (about A.D . 10-220), is that of the growth of the Mishnah.' Among the best known representatives of the schools are Rabban (a See also:title given to Hillel's descendants) See also:Gamaliel, the Phil-Hellene and teacher of the apostle See also:Paul (Acts xxii . 3) and his son Simeon (Josephus, Life, § 38 seq., See also:Wars, iv .

3, 9), and Rabban Jol}anan b . Zakkai, founder of the seat of learning at See also:

Jamnia (Jabneh) . A little later (about 90-130 A.D.) are the famous Gamaliel II., Eliezer b . Hyrqanos (at Lydda), and See also:Ishmael b . See also:Elisha, the last of whom founded the school at Usha and is renowned for his development of the rules of exegesis framed by Hillel . With Rabbi Aqiba (q.v.) and the synods of Jamnia (about 90 and 118 A.D.) a definite See also:epoch in Judaism begins . At Jamnia, under the See also:presidency of Gamaliel II. and Eleazar b . See also:Azariah, a collection of traditional halakoth was formed in the tractate 'Eduyyoth (larger than and not to be identified with IV., 7 above) . Here, too, was discussed the canonicity of the See also:Song of Songs and of See also:Ecclesiastes, and it is probable that here Aqiba and his colleagues fixed the See also:official text of the canonical books . Aqiba had an important See also:share in the early development of the Mishnah (Strack, pp . 19, 89); and, in the collecting of material, he was followed notably by the school of Ishmael (about 13o-16o A.D.), which has See also:left its mark upon the early halakic Midrashim (see MIoRASu, § 5, 1-3) . The more interesting names include R .

See also:

Meir, a well-known haggadist, R . Simeon b . Yohai, R . Jose b . IJalaphta and R . Jehudah b . 'El'ai . But, as collections of decisions were made by prominent teachers from time to time, confusion was caused by their See also:differences as regards both contents and teaching (Sotah, 22a; Shabb . 138b) . Consequently, towards the See also:close of the second century a thoroughly comprehensive effort was made to reduce the halakoth to order . See also:Judah, See also:grandson of Gamaliel II., known as the See also:Prince or See also:Patriarch (ndsi'), as Rabbenu (" our teacher "), or simply as " Rabbi " See also:par excellence, was the editor . He gathered together the material, using Meir's collection as a basis, and although he did not write the Mishnah as it now is, he brought it into essentially its present shape .

His methods were not See also:

free from arbitrariness; he would attribute to " the wise " the See also:opinion of a single authority which he regarded as correct; he would ignore conflicting opinions or those of scholars which they themselves had afterwards retracted, and he did not See also:scruple to cite his own decisions .2 The period of the 'AAmord'im, " speakers, interpreters," (about 220—500 A.D.), witnessed the growth of the Gemara, when the now " canonical " Mishnah formed the basis for further amplification and for the collecting of old and new material which See also:bore upon it . In See also:Palestine learning flourished at Caesarea, Sepphoris, See also:Tiberias and Usha; Babylonia had famous schools at Nehardea (from the 2nd century A.D.), Sura, Pumbeditha and elsewhere.' Of their teachers (who were called Rabbi and See also:Rab respectively) several hundreds are known . R . IJiyya was redactor of the Siphra on See also:Leviticus (MIDRASH, § 5, 2); to him and to R . Hoshaiah the compilation of the Tosephtd is also ascribed . Abba Arika or Rab, the See also:nephew of the first mentioned, founded the school of Sura (219 A.D.) . Rab and Shemuel (See also:Samuel) " the astronomer " (died 254 A.D.) were pupils of " Rabbi " (i.e . Judah, above), and were famed for their know-ledge of law; so numerous were their points of difference that the Talmud will emphasize certain decisions by the statement that the two were agreed . The Gemara is much indebted to this pair and to Johanan b . Nappaha (199-279) . The latter, founder of the great school of Tiberias, has indeed been On the various teachers, especially the Haggadists, see W . Bacher, Agada der See also:Babylon .

Amoraer (See also:

Strassburg, 1879), A. d . Tannaiten (1884, new edition begun in 1903), A. d . See also:Pal . Amorder (1892) . 2 See the criticisms in Jew . Ency., viii . 612, and J . Bassfreund, Monatsschrift f. d . Gesch. u . Wissens. d . Judentums, 1907, pp . 427 sqq .

On the earlier stages, see Jew . Ency., viii . 6io, and Hastings' Diet . Bible, v . 61, See also:

col . 2, with the references . On these schools, see art . JEws, § 42 seq.; and Jew . Ency., i . 145-148.venerated, on the authority of See also:Maimonides, as the editor of the Palestinian Talmud; but the presence of later material and of later names, e.g . Mani b . Jona and Jose b .

Abin (Abun), refute this view . The Babylonian Rabbah b . Nahmani (d. c . 330) had a dialectical ability which won him the title " uprooter of moun tains." His controversies with R . See also:

Joseph b . IJiyya (known for his learning as " Sinai "), and those between their disciples See also:Aba.yi and Raba are responsible for many of the See also:minute discussions in the Babylonian Gemara . Meanwhile the persecutions of See also:Constantine and See also:Constantius brought about the decay of the Palestinian schools, and, probably in the 5th century, their recension of the Talmud was essentially complete . In Babylonia, however, learning still flourished, and with Rab Ashi (352-427) the arranging of the present framework of the Gemara may have been taken in hand . Under See also:Rabba Tosepha'a (died 470) and Rabina, i.e . Rab Abina (died 499), heads of the See also:academy of Sura, the Babylonian recension became practically complete . Finally, the Sabora'e, " explainers, opiners " (about 500-540), made some additions of their own in the way of explanations and new decisions . They may be looked upon as the last editors of the now unwieldy thesaurus; less probable is the view, often maintained since See also:Rashi (11th century), that it was first written down in their age.' 4 .

The Two Talmuds.—The Palestinian recension of the Mishnah and Gemara is called " the Talmud of the See also:

Land of See also:Israel," or " T. of the See also:West "; a popular but misleading name is " the Jerusalem Talmud." It is an extremely uneven compilation . " What was reduced to writing does not give us a work carried out after a preconcerted See also:plan, but rather represents a series of jottings answering to the needs of the various individual writers, and largely intended to strengthen the memory " (Schechter) . See also:Political troubles and the unhappy See also:condition of the Jews probably furnish the explanation; hence also the abundance of Palestinian haggadic literature in the Midrashim, whose " words of blessing and See also:consolation " appealed more to their feelings than did the legal writings . The Pal . Talmud did not attain the See also:eminence of the See also:sister recension, and survives in a very incomplete form, although it was perhaps once See also:fuller . It now extends only to Orders with the omission of IV . 7 and 9, and with the addition of part of VI . 7.5 The Babylonian Talmud (or Tal . Babli) contains the Gemara to 362 tractates) but the material is relatively very full, and it is about three times as large as the Pal., although the Gemara there extends to 39 tractates . In the latter the Gemara follows each See also:paragraph of the Mishnah; in the former, references are usually made to the leaves (the two pages of which are called a and b), the enumeration of the editio princeps being retained in subsequent editions . The Mishnah is written in a See also:late literary form of Hebrew; but the Gemara is in Aramaic (except the Baraithas), that of the Bab . T. being an Eastern Aram. See also:dialect (akin to Mandaitic), that of the Pal .

T. being Western Aram . (akin to Biblical Aram. and the Targums) . Greek was well understood in cultured Palestine; hence the latter recension uses many Greek terms which it does not explain; whereas in the Bab . T. they are much less common, and are sometimes punningly interpreted.° The Pal . Tal. is the more concise, but it is remarkable for the numerous repetitions of the same passages; these are useful for the criticism of the text, and for the See also:

light they throw upon the incompleteness of the work of compilation . The Bab . Tal., on the other hand, is diffuse and freer in its See also:composition, and it is characterized by the exuberance of Halakah, which is usually rather subtle and far-fetched . Both Talmuds offer a good See also:field for See also:research (see below) . Especially interesting are the Baraithas which are preserved in the Gemara in Hebrew; they are " See also:external " decisions not included in the more authoritative See Strack, p . 16 seq . The view has little in its favour, although memory played a more important part then than now . For early mnemonic See also:aids to the Mishnah, see Strack, p .

Phoenix-squares

68, Jew . Ency.,xii . 19 . ° The Mishnah was first critically edited by W . H . See also:

Lowe (See also:Cam-See also:bridge, 1883) . ° The Greek words are treated by S . Krauss and I . See also:Low, Griech. u . See also:Lat . Lehnworter (Berlin, 1898-9) . For the See also:Persian elements in the Bab .

T., see Jew . Ency., vii . 313 . Mishnah, but they differ from and are sometimes older than the Mishnic material, with which they sometimes conflict (so in particular as regards the rejected decisions of the school of Shammai) . They usually begin: " our Masters taught," " it is taught," or " he taught," the verb tend (cf . Tannd'im, " teachers ") being employed (see further Jew . Ency., ii . 513 seq.) . Parallel to the Mishnah is the Tosephtd, an See also:

independent compilation associated with R . See also:Nehemiah (a contemporary of Meir and Simeon b . Yohai), Hiyya b . Abba and others; it is arranged according to the Mishnic orders and tractates, but lacks IV .

9 and V . 9–11 . The halakoth are fuller and sometimes older than the corresponding decisions in the Mishnah, and the treatment is generally more haggadic.l The method of making the discussions part of an interpretation of the Old Testament (halakic Midrash), as exemplified in the Tosephtd, is apparently older than the abstract and independent decisions of the Mishnah—which presuppose an acquaintance with the Pentateuchal basis—and, like the employment of narrative or historical Midrash (e.g. in the Pentateuch, See also:

Chronicles and Jubilees), was more suitable for popular exposition than for the See also:academies . For other halakic literature which goes back to the period of the See also:Tanna'Im, see the Mekiltd, Siphrd and Siphre, art . MIDRASH, § 5, 1–3 . The Palestinian Talmud, although used by the See also:Qaraites in their controversies, See also:fell into neglect, and the Babylonian recension became, what it has since been, the authoritative See also:guide . With the Geonim, the heads of Sura and Pumbeditha (about 589–Io38), we enter upon another See also:stage . The " canonical " Mishnah and Gemara were now the See also:objects of study, and the scattered Jews appealed to the central bodies of Judaism in Babylonia for information and guidance . The Geonim in their " Responses " or " Questions and Answers " supplied authoritative interpretations of the Old Testament or of the Talmud, and regulated the application of the teaching of the past to the changed conditions under which their brethren now lived . The legal, religious and other decisions formulated in the pontifical communications of one See also:generation usually became the venerated teaching of the next, and a new class of literature thus sprang into existence . (See See also:GAON.) Meanwhile, as the Babylonian schools decayed, Talmudic learning was assiduously pursued outside its oriental See also:home, and some Babylonian Talmudists apparently reached the West . However, the fortunes of the Talmud in a hostile